Wise ol Ben, Answered

According to the receipt given to me by CoinStar, the Culligan bottle contained:
Item   Quantity

Dollars (coin) 1 
Quarters  461   
Dimes     322
Nickels   130    
Pennies  483

ADD

Dollars (paper) 8 

AND
1 plastic button (now how'd that get in there?)

Total value $167.78

Closest guess $193.43 (happysunshine came within $25.64)

Now I'm off to spend that money.  Time for me to take a break from the demands of work and go have some fun!  See ya when I return...